Script Differences Hinder Language Switching in Bilinguals
Researchers at the HSE Centre for Language and Brain used eye-tracking to examine how bilinguals switch between languages in response to context shifts. Script differences were found to slow down this process. When letters appear unfamiliar—such as the Latin alphabet in a Russian-language text—the brain does not immediately switch to the other language, even when the person is aware they are in a bilingual setting. The article has been published in Bilingualism: Language and Cognition.
Bilinguals can differentiate between the target and non-target languages based on the global language context. In an environment where everyone speaks Russian, a bilingual fluent in both Russian and English will experience suppression of their English. In this context, Russian becomes the target language, while English remains the non-target language.
The researchers aimed to investigate how switching between target and non-target languages occurs when the global language context changes and to test the hypothesis of proactive gain control in bilinguals. This hypothesis suggests that as exposure to a non-target language increases, bilinguals activate its vocabulary to facilitate faster use. It is important that such control is exercised proactively rather than in response to already received information, and this helps prevent processing delays.
To test this hypothesis, the researchers conducted an experiment with a sample of 50 adult Russian–English bilinguals. Participants were asked to read several sentences on various topics displayed on a computer screen and answer related questions. Initially, participants' target language was Russian, but the researchers gradually altered the language context to make English the target language. Initially, Russian was the only language spoken to participants, and they were given task instructions in Russian. In the second stage, English sentences were introduced alongside Russian. In the third stage, English sentences were removed, but an English-speaking instructor joined the participants. In the final stage, participants were exposed solely to English sentences, and the experimenter spoke only English to them.
As participants performed the tasks, their eye movements were recorded, specifically the duration of gaze fixation on a word, the number of regressions to previous words, and any skipped words. It is known that longer fixations indicate greater difficulty in processing a word, while regressions suggest a need to revisit the word to better understand its meaning.
'The invisible boundary paradigm was used to measure access to the non-target language. While a participant was reading a sentence in Russian, an English translation of a word in that sentence briefly appeared before the target Russian word was displayed,' the authors explain.
For example, in the Russian sentence 'You will need to complete certain training to obtain a permit,' the English word training appeared before the Russian word for ‘training.’
The researchers hypothesised that if access to the English language was activated, the duration of fixation on the Russian word after the appearance of its English translation would be shorter. However, this hypothesis was not confirmed. Despite the gradual introduction of English elements in the experiment, changes in the linguistic context did not influence early lexical access.
'Probably, the difference between the Cyrillic and Latin scripts is too significant, causing the brain to immediately recognise the mismatch and automatically suppress the non-target script. Additionally, it is possible that the immersion in the non-target language was not prolonged enough for its activation,' the researchers suggest.
Thus, the study findings confirmed the key predictions of the Multilink and BIA+ models, namely that lexical processing in a bilingual environment is influenced by both bottom-up and top-down factors. However, bottom-up factors dominate when the scripts differ.
The bottom level involves automatic input processing, where the brain first recognises letters, followed by words, and then their meanings. In the case of different scripts, such as Cyrillic and Latin, the brain may struggle to recognise the letters of the non-target script. The difference significantly impacts how quickly and efficiently a person can switch between languages.
The top level involves conscious input processing, which relies on the global context and prior experience. For example, if a person knows they are in a bilingual environment, this awareness can activate an expectation in their brain of encountering a word in the second language. However, this process requires more time and effort.
The researchers plan to conduct experiments involving deeper immersion in a non-target language. 'We expect that after a certain point, we will observe an increase in the speed of cross-language switching,' explain the authors.
The findings from this and potential future studies may be valuable for developing strategies to teach foreign languages, particularly reading skills, by considering the cognitive load involved in suppressing the native language, script differences, and the duration of immersion in the language environment.
See also:
Similar Comprehension, Different Reading: How Native Language Affects Reading in English as a Second Language
Researchers from the MECO international project, including experts from the HSE Centre for Language and Brain, have developed a tool for analysing data on English text reading by native speakers of more than 19 languages. In a large-scale experiment involving over 1,200 people, researchers recorded participants’ eye movements as they silently read the same English texts and then assessed their level of comprehension. The results showed that even when comprehension levels were the same, the reading process—such as gaze fixations, rereading, and word skipping—varied depending on the reader's native language and their English proficiency. The study has been published in Studies in Second Language Acquisition.
Mortgage and Demography: HSE Scientists Reveal How Mortgage Debt Shapes Family Priorities
Having a mortgage increases the likelihood that a Russian family will plan to have a child within the next three years by 39 percentage points. This is the conclusion of a study by Prof. Elena Vakulenko and doctoral student Rufina Evgrafova from the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences. The authors emphasise that this effect is most pronounced among women, people under 36, and those without children. The study findings have been published in Voprosy Ekonomiki.
Scientists Discover How Correlated Disorder Boosts Superconductivity
Superconductivity is a unique state of matter in which electric current flows without any energy loss. In materials with defects, it typically emerges at very low temperatures and develops in several stages. An international team of scientists, including physicists from HSE MIEM, has demonstrated that when defects within a material are arranged in a specific pattern rather than randomly, superconductivity can occur at a higher temperature and extend throughout the entire material. This discovery could help develop superconductors that operate without the need for extreme cooling. The study has been published in Physical Review B.
Scientists Develop New Method to Detect Motor Disorders Using 3D Objects
Researchers at HSE University have developed a new methodological approach to studying motor planning and execution. By using 3D-printed objects and an infrared tracking system, they demonstrated that the brain initiates the planning process even before movement begins. This approach may eventually aid in the assessment and treatment of patients with neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson’s. The paper has been published in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience.
'Biotech Is Booming Worldwide'
For more than five years, the International Laboratory of Bioinformatics at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science has been advancing cutting-edge research. During this time, its scientists have achieved major breakthroughs, including the development of CARDIOLIFE—a unique genetic test unmatched worldwide that predicts the likelihood of cardiovascular disease. With the active participation of HSE students, including doctoral students, the team is also working on a new generation of medicines. In this interview with the HSE News Service, Laboratory Head Maria Poptsova shares insights into their work.
Civic Identity Helps Russians Maintain Mental Health During Sanctions
Researchers at HSE University have found that identifying with one’s country can support psychological coping during difficult times, particularly when individuals reframe the situation or draw on spiritual and cultural values. Reframing in particular can help alleviate symptoms of depression. The study has been published in Journal of Community Psychology.
Scientists Clarify How the Brain Memorises and Recalls Information
An international team, including scientists from HSE University, has demonstrated for the first time that the anterior and posterior portions of the human hippocampus have distinct roles in associative memory. Using stereo-EEG recordings, the researchers found that the rostral (anterior) portion of the human hippocampus is activated during encoding and object recognition, while the caudal (posterior) portion is involved in associative recall, restoring connections between the object and its context. These findings contribute to our understanding of the structure of human memory and may inform clinical practice. A paper with the study findings has been published in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience.
Researchers Examine Student Care Culture in Small Russian Universities
Researchers from the HSE Institute of Education conducted a sociological study at four small, non-selective universities and revealed, based on 135 interviews, the dual nature of student care at such institutions: a combination of genuine support with continuous supervision, reminiscent of parental care. This study offers the first in-depth look at how formal and informal student care practices are intertwined in the post-Soviet educational context. The study has been published in the British Journal of Sociology of Education.
AI Can Predict Student Academic Performance Based on Social Media Subscriptions
A team of Russian researchers, including scientists from HSE University, used AI to analyse 4,500 students’ subscriptions to VK social media communities. The study found that algorithms can accurately identify both high-performing students and those struggling with their studies. The paper has been published in IEEE Access.
HSE Scientists: Social Cues in News Interfaces Build Online Trust
Researchers from the HSE Laboratory for Cognitive Psychology of Digital Interface Users have discovered how social cues in the design of news websites—such as reader comments, the number of reposts, or the author’s name—can help build user trust. An experiment with 137 volunteers showed that such interface elements make a website appear more trustworthy and persuasive to users, with the strongest cue being links to the media’s social networks. The study's findings have been published in Human-Computer Interaction.