• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Neuroscientists Reveal Anna Karenina Principle in Brain's Response to Persuasion

Neuroscientists Reveal Anna Karenina Principle in Brain's Response to Persuasion

© iStock

A team of researchers at HSE University investigated the neural mechanisms involved in how the brain processes persuasive messages. Using functional MRI, the researchers recorded how the participants' brains reacted to expert arguments about the harmful health effects of sugar consumption. The findings revealed that all unpersuaded individuals' brains responded to the messages in a similar manner, whereas each persuaded individual produced a unique neural response. This suggests that successful persuasive messages influence opinions in a highly individual manner, appearing to find a unique key to each person's brain. The study findings have been published in PNAS.

Persuading people to adopt a healthier lifestyle can be accomplished through effective argumentation. For several years, researchers at the HSE Institute for Cognitive Neuroscience have been investigating how expert arguments about healthy eating can influence a person's willingness to purchase sugar-free foods, and, most importantly, which areas of the brain are involved. 

In a recent study, neuroscientists at HSE University compare the brain responses of individuals who are likely to be persuaded by expert arguments with those who resist persuasion. Unlike traditional research approaches, where participants are exposed to isolated words or phrases, the researchers presented the subjects with an expert's talk on the health risks of sugar consumption. This approach supports a more realistic laboratory simulation of persuasive communication. To obtain a comprehensive and detailed picture of neural activity in different groups of participants, the researchers employed functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Using the mathematical method of intersubject correlation analysis, the researchers then examined whether the neural responses to the healthy eating call were similar or varied across participants.

Figure 1. A illustrates the experimental procedure; B shows an example of a product evaluation task
Source © Ioannis Ntoumanis et al. Deciphering the neural responses to a naturalistic persuasive message (2024)

The experiment involved 50 participants and consisted of two parts. First, participants were asked to rate three types of products—sugar-containing, sugar-free, and non-edible—and to place bids on each by indicating how much they would be willing to pay. Next, the participants listened to a 7-minute lecture by an expert on the health risks of sugar consumption, after which they were asked to bid on the same products once again. Throughout the experiment, the researchers monitored the participants' brain activity using fMRI.

As a result of the healthy eating message, some participants changed their minds in favour of a healthier diet. The persuaded group also displayed highly varied patterns of brain activity, in particular a greater diversity of activity in the lower regions of the frontal cortex, an area crucial for decision-making and social cognition. 

In contrast, the brains of participants who were sceptical and unpersuaded by the expert's arguments processed the information all in a similar manner. They showed high synchronisation of activity in brain regions linked to self-reflection and critical assessment of information.

'We used an unconventional method to study brain activity: we examined the similarity of neural activity across a group of individuals. In scientific terms, this is referred to as "intersubject correlation of brain activity." Our findings can be described as a type of Anna Karenina effect, where the responses of those who are indifferent and immune to arguments are alike, while each persuaded individual responds in their own unique way. Apparently, an effective persuasive message can adapt to individuals' unique characteristics, targeting aspects that are particularly relevant to each listener,' explains Vasily Klyucharev, Head of the International Laboratory of Social Neurobiology and of this research project.  

Interestingly, participants influenced by the expert's talk were willing to pay more for healthy food, but the value they placed on sugar-containing food did not decrease. According to the researchers, this may be due to the structure of the audio message: towards the end, the expert emphasised the benefits of healthy eating rather than the negative effects of sugar consumption. Information that concludes a message is typically remembered best.

Ioannis Ntoumanis

'In the future, we hope to continue studying this "Anna Karenina effect" to identify the reasons behind the differences in neuronal activity among those who are persuaded. Does the effectiveness of persuasive messages depend on the chosen arguments, and what factors exactly influence people? All of this can improve the perception of public health messages, making them more personalised and, as a result, more effective,' according to Ioannis Ntoumanis, Junior Research Fellow at the International Laboratory of Social Neurobiology and co-author of the study. 

The study was conducted within the framework of the strategic project 'Human Brain Resilience: Neurocognitive Technologies for Adaptation, Learning, Development and Rehabilitation in a Changing Environment' ('Priority 2030').

See also:

HSE Researchers Teach Neural Network to Distinguish Origins from Genetically Similar Populations

Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute, HSE Faculty of Computer Science, have proposed a new approach based on advanced machine learning techniques to determine a person’s genetic origin with high accuracy. This method uses graph neural networks, which make it possible to distinguish even very closely related populations.

HSE Economists Reveal the Secret to Strong Families

Researchers from the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences have examined the key factors behind lasting marriages. The findings show that having children is the primary factor contributing to marital stability, while for couples without children, a greater income gap between spouses is associated with a stronger union. This is the conclusion reported in Applied Econometrics.

Fifteen Minutes on Foot: How Post-Soviet Cities Manage Access to Essential Services

Researchers from HSE University and the Institute of Geography of the Russian Academy of Sciences analysed three major Russian cities to assess their alignment with the '15-minute city' concept—an urban design that ensures residents can easily access essential services and facilities within walking distance. Naberezhnye Chelny, where most residents live in Soviet-era microdistricts, demonstrated the highest levels of accessibility. In Krasnodar, fewer than half of residents can easily reach essential facilities on foot, and in Saratov, just over a third can. The article has been published in Regional Research of Russia.

HSE Researchers Find Counter-Strike Skins Outperform Bitcoin and Gold as Alternative Investments

Virtual knives, custom-painted machine guns, and gloves are common collectible items in videogames. A new study by scientists from HSE University suggests that digital skins from the popular video game Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (CS:GO) rank among the most profitable types of alternative investments, with average annual returns exceeding 40%. The study has been published in the Social Science Research Network (SSRN), a free-access online repository.

HSE Neurolinguists Reveal What Makes Apps Effective for Aphasia Rehabilitation

Scientists at the HSE Centre for Language and Brain have identified key factors that increase the effectiveness of mobile and computer-based applications for aphasia rehabilitation. These key factors include automated feedback, a variety of tasks within the application, extended treatment duration, and ongoing interaction between the user and the clinician. The article has been published in NeuroRehabilitation.

'Our Goal Is Not to Determine Which Version Is Correct but to Explore the Variability'

The International Linguistic Convergence Laboratory at the HSE Faculty of Humanities studies the processes of convergence among languages spoken in regions with mixed, multiethnic populations. Research conducted by linguists at HSE University contributes to understanding the history of language development and explores how languages are perceived and used in multilingual environments. George Moroz, head of the laboratory, shares more details in an interview with the HSE News Service.

Slim vs Fat: Overweight Russians Earn Less

Overweight Russians tend to earn significantly less than their slimmer counterparts, with a 10% increase in body mass index (BMI) associated with a 9% decrease in wages. These are the findings made by Anastasiia Deeva, lecturer at the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences and intern researcher in Laboratory of Economic Research in Public Sector. The article has been published in Voprosy Statistiki.

Scientists Reveal Cognitive Mechanisms Involved in Bipolar Disorder

An international team of researchers including scientists from HSE University has experimentally demonstrated that individuals with bipolar disorder tend to perceive the world as more volatile than it actually is, which often leads them to make irrational decisions. The scientists suggest that their findings could lead to the development of more accurate methods for diagnosing and treating bipolar disorder in the future. The article has been published in Translational Psychiatry.

Scientists Develop AI Tool for Designing Novel Materials

An international team of scientists, including researchers from HSE University, has developed a new generative model called the Wyckoff Transformer (WyFormer) for creating symmetrical crystal structures. The neural network will make it possible to design materials with specified properties for use in semiconductors, solar panels, medical devices, and other high-tech applications. The scientists will present their work at ICML, a leading international conference on machine learning, on July 15 in Vancouver. A preprint of the paper is available on arxiv.org, with the code and data released under an open-source license.

HSE Linguists Study How Bilinguals Use Phrases with Numerals in Russian

Researchers at HSE University analysed over 4,000 examples of Russian spoken by bilinguals for whom Russian is a second language, collected from seven regions of Russia. They found that most non-standard numeral constructions are influenced not only by the speakers’ native languages but also by how frequently these expressions occur in everyday speech. For example, common phrases like 'two hours' or 'five kilometres’ almost always match the standard literary form, while less familiar expressions—especially those involving the numerals two to four or collective forms like dvoe and troe (used for referring to people)—often differ from the norm. The study has been published in Journal of Bilingualism.